Competition formats

(13-12-2019 19:50 )Joey 27 Wrote:  don''t you dare say im wrong to accuse Winsaw of match fixing,

You're wrong to accuse Winsaw of match fixing.

I think whatever is decided it has to keep everyone happy. The mods, those who run and organise the competitions, and those who are voting.

I stand with Silent Joey to say you're wrong to accuse winsaw of match fixing. He did the next best thing and did the play off, and restarted the vote, so he did the right thing, apologised and restarted.

My thoughts having looked at all the comments is I don't think the process is broke I like the way the different votes are run different I think it adds interest,
What I have learned is it's no good doing things right u have to be seen to be doing them right so everyone beleive what they see ,
I think next year keep November and December for the ultimate awards, newcomer and the queens of each channel so is not to much going on at same time, and put the different new body awards on in January when the forum and the shows are quieter and the fun they bring would be a real boost to everyone at that time of year,
I would like to see a committee of say 5 voted for by everyone on here to pick 2 or 3 girls to go into the hall of fame who are worthy but are unlikely to ever win a public vote ( which should still be going on as well to pick the main girl ),
And lastly I have learned that Joey really is a little Princess

Seriously though a good thread with good ideas in

I like the idea of a committee for the HOF vote but I do think it should remain as a vote held by members of the forum and not just a committee. it has a format to it that works and to have a committee pick 2- 3 other girls to go into the hall would probably still raise arguments as many would say their place wouldn't be justified in the HOF as they weren't voted in by us, etc. I'm sure some will agree it is a good idea but does take a little away from the vote held, if 3 - 4 girls were inducted when only one won the member's vote 'as it were'.

Plus I feel the HOF should be held around end of October to early Nov to be the lead - in competition for the others to follow.
OR

should we try this idea : -
We move the HOF vote earlier in the year say end spring to early summer then we have a vote that allows & inducts at the same time the channel queens into the HOF in OCT/NOV?

^^ true I just think it would bring it in line with most hof which are a mix of fans vote and committee, maybe the committee could come up.with a short list that is then voted on, I don't think it takes away from the hof if anything makes it stronger,

^ I like the idea of a committee to put forward HoF nominees. It would concentrate the voting process to a shortlist of truly worthy candidates and their “qualifications” could be described as part of the vote launch process.

Cue the debate as to who is selected to be on the committee .

(15-12-2019 13:53 )snookered Wrote:  Cue the debate as to who is selected to be on the committee .

We could always have a vote

What is needed in all competitions is transparency. Or as much as possible.
With the Offical Forum competition the Hall of Fame award everything has to be visible to all. No random draws just the seeding of the girls.

On the forum every member is the same as every other. So one members nominations are as good as any others nominations.

Rules sometimes need changing and I welcome any messages with any way that we could inprove the award.
We are grateful for Babelover for fronting the HOF awards for the last few years. But the running of the award is a team effort.

(15-12-2019 14:00 )Charlemagne Wrote:  No random draws just the seeding of the girls.

I'm sure cwpussylover would volunteer to seed them all