Has VAR ruined football?

Yes

(05-05-2024 03:28 )lovebabes56 Wrote:  I feel the referee should be given far more freedom to use his own gut instinct where possible and overrule VAR advice.

You clearly don't understand how VAR works. The referee can already disregard any advice from VAR if he chooses, just as he can disregard any advice from his assistants on the field of play. The referee doesn't need any freedom to decide what to do with advice from VAR - because the final decision always rests with the referee anyway.

The Premier League clubs will vote on 6th June as to whether to scrap VAR from next season in the AGM.

Wolves have submitted a resolution to trigger such a vote.

Statement from Wolves.

The introduction of VAR in 2019/20 was a decision made in good faith and with the best interests of football and the Premier League at its heart. However, it has led to numerous unintended negative consequences that are damaging the relationship between fans and football, and undermining the value of the Premier League brand, which include:

• Impact on goal celebrations and the spontaneous passion that makes football special.

• Frustration and confusion inside stadiums due to lengthy VAR checks and poor communication.

•A more hostile atmosphere with protests, booing of the Premier League anthem and chants against VAR.

• Overreach of VAR's original purpose to correct clear and obvious mistakes, now overanalysing subjective decisions and compromising the game's fluidity and integrity.

• Diminished accountability of on-field officials, due to safety net of VAR, leading to an erosion of authority on the pitch.

• Continued errors despite VAR, with supporters unable to accept human error after multiple views and replays, damaging confidence in officiating standards.

• Disruption of the Premier League's fast pace with lengthy VAR checks and more added time, causing matches to run excessively long.

• Constant discourse about VAR decisions often overshadowing the match itself, and tarnishing the reputation of the league.

• Erosion of trust and reputation, with VAR fuelling completely nonsensical allegations of corruption.

The decision to table the resolution has come after careful consideration and with the utmost respect for the Premier League, PGMOL and our fellow competitors.

There is no blame to be placed - we are all just looking for the best possible outcome for football - and all stakeholders have been working hard to try and make the introduction of additional technology a success.

However, after five seasons of VAR in the Premier League it is time for a constructive and critical debate on its future.

Our position is that the price we are paying for a small increase in accuracy is at odds with the spirit of our game, and as a result we should remove it from the 2024/25 season onwards

I would say it is a debate long and overdue for most fans I think.
I'm hoping that some clubs will back Wolves, and have the same greivances as them, but I feel there are many clubs who will vote it down

BBC: Fifa trials tennis-style VAR reviews in youth football

VAR in the Premier League 2023/24

Matches played - 380
Decisions changed after VAR interventions - 108

Breakdown
Decisions changed on foul play - 44
Decisions changed on offsides - 40
Decisions changed on handball - 19
Whether in penalty area or not - 4
Whether ball was in play or not - 1
Total no. of changed decisions - 108

VAR will be better next season with the introduction of semi-automated offside technology.

Wolves failed to receive any support in their bid to get VAR scrapped, with the Premier League clubs voting 19-1 today to keep the video assistant.

The PL said they will look at improvements

which probavbly will amount to FA.