Mayweather, Pacquiao, who wins?

Dodgy scoring in boxing .
Surely not .
The integrity of all judges is surely beyond any doubt .

*snookered's sides split with laughter .

my heart say Pac man in about 9

(30-04-2015 23:20 )Whynot Wrote:  

(30-04-2015 22:11 )Broncobilly Wrote:  On what grounds can Pac win? He has lost to people mayweather has already beaten

If we are playing this game.... Mayweather lost to De La Hoya (watch the fight, oscar won the first 8 rounds clearly) ... Pacquiao retired him.

Mayweather lost to Luis Castillo (again watch the fight, this was daylight robbery) but got decision.

Pacquiao took on Cotto who everyone avoided, gave him weight and stopped him... Mayweather in comparison struggled with Cotto after manny had beaten him.

Records can be deceiving, both are great fighters, but the fact Mayweather has a 0 does not mean his record is better!!

Manny lost to Marquez, well watch those fights, pure poetry from both men His lost to Bradley.. fuck me corrupt scoring, it was almost funny.

I would expect Khan would not get a look in whoever won, and I have to say of late some of decisions involving Mayweather were dodgy to say the least, but would Froch be scared of either of them?

(29-04-2015 19:28 )Whynot Wrote:  the cynic in me says the draw fair or foul, would make them both happy as the rematch would generate even more revenue.

It doesn't have to be a draw in order for there to be a rematch. A narrow decision either way would still set a rematch up.

If we get a decent ref that allows Pacman to work inside unlike the ref for Hatton v May weather then I would go for Pacman, but we will probably get a Mayweather ref that allows him to win

I don't think Pacquiao can win on points. He probably needs to stop Mayweather to beat him.

It's just a pity this fight didn't happen 4 or 5 years ago.

The only reason it didn't happen 4 or 5 years ago was because of the money that Mayweather probably wanted at the tome. Either way this fight will finish one career.

(30-04-2015 23:20 )Whynot Wrote:  

(30-04-2015 22:11 )Broncobilly Wrote:  On what grounds can Pac win? He has lost to people mayweather has already beaten

If we are playing this game.... Mayweather lost to De La Hoya (watch the fight, oscar won the first 8 rounds clearly) ... Pacquiao retired him.

Mayweather lost to Luis Castillo (again watch the fight, this was daylight robbery) but got decision.

Pacquiao took on Cotto who everyone avoided, gave him weight and stopped him... Mayweather in comparison struggled with Cotto after manny had beaten him.

Records can be deceiving, both are great fighters, but the fact Mayweather has a 0 does not mean his record is better!!

Manny lost to Marquez, well watch those fights, pure poetry from both men His lost to Bradley.. fuck me corrupt scoring, it was almost funny.

It think the Bradly result was the one that called judge scoring into question I believe how that scoring was allowed to stand is beyond me

(30-04-2015 23:33 )snookered147 Wrote:  Dodgy scoring in boxing .
Surely not .
The integrity of all judges is surely beyond any doubt .

*snookered's sides split with laughter .

Which is one of the main reasons why I tend to watch UFC over boxing these days. The fights are often settled in the ring without the need for some biased/blind judge poking their oar in

Onto the boxing... I think Mayweather will probably dance & dodge and win on points, which could end up rather frustrating to watch. Especially if your like me and you really want Manny to catch him and end the smugness

(02-05-2015 05:49 )Bandwagon Wrote:  

(30-04-2015 23:33 )snookered147 Wrote:  Dodgy scoring in boxing .
Surely not .
The integrity of all judges is surely beyond any doubt .

*snookered's sides split with laughter .

Which is one of the main reasons why I tend to watch UFC over boxing these days. The fights are often settled in the ring without the need for some biased/blind judge poking their oar in

Onto the boxing... I think Mayweather will probably dance & dodge and win on points, which could end up rather frustrating to watch. Especially if your like me and you really want Manny to catch him and end the smugness

I agree UFC doesn't have the same problem with judge scoring but at the same time there will come a point and a fight and scoring which will prove controversial and then their judge scoring is called in question!! I'd love to see mayweather take on the UFC welterweight or middleweight champ and see how does... it will wipe the smugness out of him forever