**Ultimate Babe 2011** - Discussion, suggestions, opinions...

(13-11-2011 12:03 )Boomerangutangangbang Wrote:  I was thinking along similar lines as winsaw.Maybe a maximum of 6 votes for Freeview babes,so if you use all 10
votes 4 must be Skx only babes.As it stands in the current system,if you take into account BS & Elite's large rosters,Freeview viewers are unable to vote for approximately 40% of the Sky babes.Even if you factor in the Elite/BS fanboys,surely some Sky babes would make their top 10

Nice idea, but even under the present system, despite putting the regulations in red ink and block capitals look how many people tried to vote for day girls, tease hour girls and ineligible girls. Trying to get people to comply with a "six maximum" rule would lead to even more problems.

(13-11-2011 12:03 )Boomerangutangangbang Wrote:  Maybe a maximum of 6 votes for Freeview babes,so if you use all 10
votes 4 must be Skx only babes.

That's just a variation of the "massively flawed" Rugi system. I also agree with the point above from mr williams.

(13-11-2011 10:12 )winsaw Wrote:  i would have gone for a handicapping system, were you could still vote for any girl you like but if she worked for elite or BS she would need more votes than a sky only girl to get the same number of points in the list

(13-11-2011 12:36 )BarrieBF Wrote:  

(13-11-2011 12:03 )Boomerangutangangbang Wrote:  Maybe a maximum of 6 votes for Freeview babes,so if you use all 10
votes 4 must be Skx only babes.

That's just a variation of the "massively flawed" Rugi system. I also agree with the point above from mr williams.

Sorry,not familiar with the Rugi system.What we're saying is fair would be 2 separate comps-Freeview Only & Sky Only.

Yeah, any system is going to have it's drawbacks, there are far too many variables around but I think the way we did it is the most open and fair way of doing it.

Also, in terms of 'Best Newcomer of the Year', isn't this also Paige Green's first year? In which case, she recieved 10 more points than Jennifer Jade so, sadly for us Jennifer fans, Paige would need to be handed that title.

10 points!! oooo close one Congrats to Paige Green too, she is one of my favs as well.

Cant wait to see the full list with points, but lets see the winner through first

Edit: to be fair, just checked and think Paige started in November 2010 if that makes a difference. (Now I feel bad for pointing that out! Sorry Paige.)

(13-11-2011 12:51 )Scotsman Wrote:  Yeah, any system is going to have it's drawbacks, there are far too many variables around but I think the way we did it is the most open and fair way of doing it.

Also, in terms of 'Best Newcomer of the Year', isn't this also Paige Green's first year? In which case, she recieved 10 more points than Jennifer Jade so, sadly for us Jennifer fans, Paige would need to be handed that title.

But Paige had the advantage of being available on Freeview so them 10 extra points could have come from that. Paige also would have brought her daytime fans to the vote whereas Jennifer was completely new to us.

(13-11-2011 13:01 )londonpete72 Wrote:  But Paige had the advantage of being available on Freeview so them 10 extra points could have come from that. Paige also would have brought her daytime fans to the vote whereas Jennifer was completely new to us.

Don't forget to total up how many night shows and how many hours each girl appeared this year and apply the relevant handicap points for those too. And of course handicap points for channel location in the Sky EPG - surely one of the channels has extra benefit from that. And even if a girl has appeared on more shows than another, are they the most prominent days? I think its important to take into account which days each girl appeared on and handicap accordingly. All in the sake of fairness.

Elite wasnt on freeview last year but still dominated these babe of the year awards, if freeview was that much of a factor wouldnt a bs/bang babes girls of won?

Maybe the reason rlc doesn't figure that much, is because of the sheer amount of girls they've had on over the year, where as bs/elite have pretty much had the same girls all year

Im really surprised by the results, only Daryl Morgan got through from the 10 I chose. Am I correct in thinking that apart from Dannii Harwood all the girls are from either Elite or Babestation? I really thought Ashleigh and Courtney from Storm would get through.

The girls outside of the 'big 3' didn't do that well, though Ashleigh was the highest placed. Sophie Hart, HOney Scott, Elle P, Jasmine and Cali Garcia were the next closest.

The RLC girls had a pretty solid number each but only Dannii Harwood really ran away with it, Lucy, Jennifer and Dionne were fairly close though.