Phones on BSXtra - Yes or No?

All you have to do is click on "yes" or "no" above then click "vote" button

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the whole point of bsxtra was to interact with the babes via texts and pics and now they dont

Voted No.
Come on Producers!: you may make more money with a phoneline in the short-term, but you're alienating a lot of loyal viewers in the process!

sorry but i prefer the phones to be honest. bsextra was a disaster when they spend more time looking at blokes wangs than reading texts out. was a good idea but like eveything off on the channels good idea executed poorly. im guessing BSX freeview will become BS extreme and the sky channel will become bs3 or if they have sense bring back party girls for sky viewers only ( can see villa starting to get angry at the very idea lol )

As I said in the other thread, I would rather have phones. Watching girls rating wangs on a whiteboard isn't exactly my idea of good TV, so if the alternative is a girl on the phone with her boobs out, I would rather watch that.

the rating of wangs does get boring but do like the babes bantering with each other and the random comments they come out with so think a compromise between phone and texts should be reached

They weren't rating 'wangs' when the show started out with the boxes showing the other channels and all the chat about what was happening and who was on or going to be on where etc etc. It all worked very well in that format.

(04-04-2010 09:16 )HannahsPet Wrote:  ( can see villa starting to get angry at the very idea lol )

Anyway, it's the virtually full nightly coverage of BS1 on Ch 96 that we're losing, which makes me even more angry.

(04-04-2010 11:34 )vila Wrote:  They weren't rating 'wangs' when the show started out with the boxes showing the other channels and all the chat about what was happening and who was on or going to be on where etc etc. It all worked very well in that format.

Donna Duke moaned about Cellcast stealing "her" idea, and that format was soon dropped.

Actually, I've pressed the wrong button there so discount one of the votes for no phones. The whole BSXtra format had become absolutely terrible to watch I'm afraid. Some people may get enjoyment from watching girls scribble names on boards but it's not for me. And truth be told, almost 75% of the texts make me cringe so much that I have to switch over in any case.

I definately prefer the girls with phones on BS extra. Seeing that stuff being written down on the boards is cringeworthy. The channels should be just about seeing the girls, and not seeing how big some bloke's dick is.

Leave it as it has been the past few days, with just phones and the girls on the sofa (or cheys-longe!!)... and is there any chance Geri and Jodie could do more phone time please?